Discussion about this post

User's avatar
sean anderson's avatar

Collective guilt versus collective liability: During the last administration DEI activists were allowed to run amuck with policies that in effect punished largely white, male, heterosexual men for supposed white male collective guilt for crimes of racism and sexism committed by earlier long dead generations. As Thomas Sowell noted it is an anomaly of our times that in America one group of currently living people is being held culpable for the alleged crimes of long dead forefathers and being made to paid reparations to other groups for what their long dead ancestors supposedly suffered at the hands of the other group’s long dead ancestors. According to Deuteronomy 24:16 “The fathers shall not be put to death for the sins of the sons nor shall the sons be put to death for the sins of the father but each man must bear his own sin.” Dr, Viktor Frankl, a Viennese psychiatrist whose wife, brother and parents were murdered by German Nazis and who himself survived four concentration camps, opposed the idea of collective guilt by later generations of Germans. While he opposed the idea of collective guilt he did propose that there was such a thing as collective liability to prevent such crimes in the future. E.g. if a man was a murderer and a thief his son could not be executed for his father’s murders but before inheriting his father’s estate any debts owed to the parties whom the father defrauded must be repaid before the remaining balance of the estate (if any remained) could be inherited. Likewise it may not be possible to identify and punish all of the many nameless people responsible for the excesses of the Biden administration but we owe it to ourselves and our descendants to fix whatever systemic glitches permitted those excesses in the first place. As a Republic we cannot allow executive powers belonging exclusively to the elected President from being wielded by family members and political cronies not elected to hold such powers.But those living persons who can be identified for criminal usurpation of executive powers should be tried and, if found guilty, punished in an appropriate manner.

No posts

Ready for more?